On January 31, 1958, the Evening Star ran a story about a psychiatrist who had spent two days examining Dallas O. Williams. The paper called him “the ‘Bad Man of Swampoodle'” and reported that the doctor had found him “sane though potentially dangerous.” Williams’s repeated trials and stays at St. Elizabeths Hospital had already raised difficult questions about the District’s insanity defense and its rules for involuntary hospitalization.
The nickname stuck in the Star‘s editorials and trial coverage. By the time Williams killed two men at a Florida Avenue gas station in March 1961, the paper had been using it for at least three years.
The name reached back to an older Washington. Much of Swampoodle, the Irish neighborhood near North Capitol Street, had been cleared for Union Station and its rail yards before Williams was born around 1915. But the name survived the demolition, turning up decades later in the coverage of his cases.
The neighborhood behind the nickname
Construction of Union Station and its approaches transformed Swampoodle in the early 1900s. I have written about that neighborhood elsewhere. The houses in this photograph show part of what was lost.

The name was still familiar to Washington readers in the 1950s, even though the streets had changed. Its appearance in Williams’s nickname does not, by itself, tell us where he lived or how the label began.

Ten convictions by thirty-four
The clearest summary of Williams’s record comes from the D.C. Circuit’s opinion on his murder convictions. Judge J. Skelly Wright described his earlier record this way:
Dallas Williams is not a newcomer to this court, or to courts generally. Without counting many other brushes with the law, by 1949, at the age of only 34 and despite incarceration during most of his adult life, he had been convicted of ten crimes of violence.
The Star had reported an even longer arrest record in March 1961: “more than 100 arrests” over twenty years. Arrests and convictions are different measures, but both accounts show how often Williams had been through the courts.
On the night of September 26, 1949, Williams shot and wounded two men. He was thirty-four. That single charge of assault with a deadly weapon became the central case of his life. The case would drag on through years of trials and hospital stays, without a conviction that survived appeal.

Five trials, three reversals
The 1949 charge went to trial five times between 1950 and 1956. Three of those trials ended in conviction. All three convictions were set aside.
The Evening Star, on February 3, 1953, covered an early mistrial with a line that would echo through the rest of the decade: “two psychiatrists testified that while Williams is now of unsound mind, they could not say whether he was mentally unbalanced at the time of the assault on September 26, 1949.”
By April 1955, the Star was reporting that “while awaiting trial a second time, Williams developed what psychiatrists termed ‘prison psychosis.’ He was committed to St. Elizabeths.” The repeated hospital stays raised a question distinct from his insanity defense: was he capable of understanding the proceedings and assisting in his defense? That is competence to stand trial. An insanity defense concerns his mental condition when the offense occurred.
The D.C. Circuit eventually vacated the last conviction on November 1, 1957, because Williams had been denied a speedy trial. Judge David Bazelon, who wrote the opinion, had also written the 1954 Durham decision. Under that rule, a defendant was not criminally responsible if the unlawful act was the product of a mental disease or defect. Bazelon’s account of what had happened to Williams was unsparing.
He has already been confined for a total of about seven years in the course of this long prosecution, about six years in jail and about a year in St. Elizabeths Hospital.
The prosecutor, at the opening of the trial Bazelon was now reversing, had told the court, “This man has the worst criminal record for violence I have ever seen.” Bazelon quoted that line in a footnote, then laid out the underlying problem.
It is both wrong and foolish to punish where there is no blame and where punishment cannot correct.
Bazelon also questioned the limited treatment Williams had received at St. Elizabeths:
In his three previous commitments to St. Elizabeths Hospital, appellant received medical treatment only to the extent necessary to restore the cognitive powers thought to be required for trial competency.
Bazelon was saying that the hospital had treated Williams chiefly to make him ready for trial. The court suggested civil commitment, a separate legal process for involuntary hospitalization, rather than another criminal trial.
The civil commitment that wasn’t
The government tried to keep Williams at St. Elizabeths through a civil-commitment petition. In January 1958, the D.C. Circuit upheld an order releasing him in Overholser v. Williams. The petition did not meet the law’s requirements:
The petition filed by the Government in this case, no matter how liberally construed, does not comply with the code provisions. For example, it completely fails to allege, as D.C. Code § 21-310 requires, that Williams is ‘insane.’ Nor is any allegation made that he is ‘of unsound mind.’
The statute, the court explained, required a verified allegation that Williams was “insane” or “of unsound mind.” The government had not made that allegation, and the attached psychiatric reports did not cure the defect.
The Star returned to the problem on January 31, 1958, in the article quoted above. A St. Elizabeths psychiatrist, Dr. J. T. Cody, had written United States Attorney Oliver C. Gasch with his findings. As the paper summarized them, Williams was “sane though potentially dangerous.”
The court had left open the possibility of a new petition that met the statutory requirements. A prediction that Williams might be dangerous was not enough to justify holding him under the defective petition.
The Star’s editorial page was, by then, openly furious. Nine days earlier, on January 22, 1958, it had run a piece headlined “Sociopathic Justice.”
Everyone knows that Justice is blind. But the case of Dallas Williams raises a suspicion that Justice, in Washington, may also be suffering, figuratively speaking, from a mental disease or defect. By what rational process of Justice has Dallas Williams been turned loose?
After further hospital commitments during a 1958 prosecution for public intoxication, the Municipal Court of Appeals returned to the issue on January 19, 1959. Judge Cayton reversed the judgments and directed dismissal of the charges, again urging officials to use the civil-commitment process:
That duty impels us to call attention, as other courts and judges have done so plainly and even urgently, to civil commitment procedure as the real solution of the problems inherent in this case.
The courts had repeatedly pointed toward civil commitment, but Williams was again at liberty before the 1961 shootings.
March 15, 1961
On the evening of March 15, 1961, Williams shot two men at the Richardson Service Station on Florida Avenue NW. Robert L. Watson, 40, was killed, and Hazel Ross, 48, died after being critically wounded. Williams was 46. The Star reported his arrest on the front page the next morning.

On March 17, the Star published an editorial titled “Reproach to Justice.” Its anger was directed at the courts and the handling of Williams’s earlier cases:
The police records say that Robert L. Watson was murdered Wednesday evening by Dallas O. Williams, who has richly earned his reputation as the “Bad Man of Swampoodle.” But it would be far more accurate to say that Watson was the victim of a fumbling, bumbling kind of justice that has been a disgrace to the National Capital.
In 20 years Williams has been arrested more than 100 times and was convicted on at least 10 occasions of crimes of violence. The most serious of these involved the shooting of two men in 1949. Eight years later, after five trials, the Court of Appeals finally reversed his conviction on the ground, not that he wasn’t guilty, but that he had been denied “a speedy trial.” A subsequent attempt to commit him as a mental case failed when four psychiatrists at St. Elizabeths said they were “completely unanimous” that Williams was not of unsound mind.
On March 27, 1961, the Star published Williams’s account, sent in a handwritten letter to reporter Dana Bullen. He said he had blacked out and did not remember the shooting. At the later trial, Detective Elroy A. Short recalled Williams making a more categorical denial:
I fight everybody with my fists. I don’t shoot anybody.
The murder trial and appeal
The double-murder case went to trial in the fall of 1961 in U.S. District Court. Williams’s mother wept in the courtroom on October 23 as the prosecutor asked the jury to find her son guilty of first-degree murder. That charge carried a mandatory death sentence in the District’s electric chair. The jury declined. It convicted on two counts of second-degree murder.

Williams appealed, and the D.C. Circuit affirmed his convictions on November 23, 1962. It denied rehearing on January 16, 1963. Eleven psychiatrists had testified at trial, and Wright’s opinion explained why their testimony did not require an insanity acquittal:
The analysis shows that while nine psychiatrists, many of them possibly influenced by appellant’s long criminal career, labelled Williams a ‘sociopathic personality,’ or thought him otherwise mentally unbalanced on the crucial date, only six characterized his condition as a ‘mental disease or defect,’ and, of these six, only three could say the killings in question were the product of that disorder.
Of the eleven psychiatrists, nine described a mental disturbance, six called it a mental disease or defect, and three connected it to the killings. That last connection was what the Durham rule required. The appeals court held that the jury could resolve the conflicting evidence, so the convictions stood.
Wright also stepped back from the dispute over testimony to describe a larger failure.
This history shows not only Williams’ failure to adjust to society, but society’s failure to find a satisfactory means of restraining offenders of his sort.
The earlier opinions had raised related concerns in 1957 and 1959. Wright returned to them after the murder convictions, while also noting that officials could consider transferring Williams from prison to a mental hospital.
What the Williams cases left behind
The D.C. Circuit replaced the Durham rule in United States v. Brawner in 1972 with a test drawn from the American Law Institute. That opinion cited Williams’s case for the point that a long criminal record did not itself excuse a crime. Williams’s cases show the disagreements courts faced under Durham, but they also involved separate questions about trial delays, competence, and civil commitment.
The insanity defense had a long history in Washington before Williams’s trials. His case is particularly revealing because the court opinions let us follow the same defendant through those different legal questions, rather than treating every hospital stay or reversal as an insanity acquittal.
The Star gave readers a memorable nickname. The court opinions tell a more complicated story, with judges repeatedly questioning whether either a prison or a hospital was dealing adequately with the man behind it.
Lost Washington stories, in your inbox.
The newest story, plus a few from the archive.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime.
We use AI to help research, write and edit stories across our sites. Here’s how we use AI.Suggest a correction

