Ghosts of DCThe lost and untold stories of Washington

Try an address, a neighborhood, a name or a year, like “14th and U” or “1968.”

Not sure where to start?

The 1966 Pagans vs. Avengers Shootout at Arlington’s Lee-Harrison Safeway

On the night of June 14, 1966, the Pagans and the Avengers turned the Safeway lot at Arlington’s Lee-Harrison Shopping Center into a gunfight. Police had been tipped off hours earlier and were watching when the first shots rang out.

Posted Updated 6 min read
· 9 min· Episode Nov 10, 2026AppleSpotify

The Safeway parking lot at the Lee-Harrison Shopping Center, at Lee Highway and North Harrison Street, is about as quiet a spot as Arlington has. On the night of Tuesday, June 14, 1966, roughly 100 shots flew across it.

Two rival gangs, the Pagans and the Avengers, had picked the lot for a showdown. The police knew it was coming. They watched the lot for hours, and nobody moved in on the crowd there until the shooting started.

Police Chief William G. Fawver called it “the most serious outbreak of mass violence this county has ever seen.” The Washington Daily News put it on the front page: “Rival Hot Rod and Cycle Clubs Have Gun Battle in Arlington; 18 Youths Held.”

Two gangs, one grudge

The Pagans Motorcycle Club was formed in 1959 by a Marylander named Lou Dobkins and was based in White Oak, Maryland. As Charles S. Clark wrote in the Arlington Historical Magazine in 2008, the Pagans “aspired to be the East Coast branch of Hell’s Angels.” In 1966 they were reported to number about 80, with only a few in Northern Virginia.

The Avengers were homegrown. Most of the local boys drawn to the gangs had gone to Williamsburg or Swanson junior high, then Yorktown or Washington-Lee, and they held day jobs as grocery clerks, drywall crewmen and house painters. The future Avengers hung around the Tops Drive-In at Lee Highway and George Mason Drive. Their leader, Wayne Hager, was a 25-year-old meat cutter for Safeway.

“We were not a gang, just a bunch of guys hanging around at Tops,” Hager told Clark in 2008. Compared with the Pagans, he said, “in the Pagans’ world of bad, we were nothing.”

The trouble started with Hager refusing to join the Pagans, which bred resentment that boiled over in late 1965, when he beat an aspiring Pagan named Frederick “Dutch” Burhans in a fistfight. A day or two later, Hager says, his parents’ house at 1705 Roosevelt Street was firebombed. Over the next months his 1965 Chevy Impala was set on fire and shot up, and the threats escalated to talk of killing him.

So Hager and his friends formed a club of their own. Just weeks before the shootout, they went to the ABC Lettering shop in downtown Washington and ordered 30 to 40 jackets with a Maltese cross and a skull. They called themselves the Avengers.

A death at North Beach

The weekend before the shootout, a Pagan from Silver Spring named Samuel Frederick ran into Hager and some Avengers in a bar in North Beach, Maryland, on the Chesapeake Bay. The Silver Spring Pagan was “called out” and fought an Avenger named Rusty O’Brien. Riding his motorcycle home that Sunday, he smashed into the back of a truck and was killed.

It was a traffic accident, but the Pagans blamed the Avengers anyway. According to Clark, they swore a “blood oath” to kill Hager, and word went out that it would all come to a head on Tuesday night at “the lot,” the Lee-Harrison Safeway.

Police watched and waited

At about 3:30 p.m. on June 14, an Arlington detective got a call from the Falls Church police warning that as many as 200 Pagans, far more than the club’s entire reported membership, were headed to an Arlington Safeway to shoot Avengers. At 5:30, the mother of a Pagan called with the same warning.

The police staked out the shopping center. Under orders worked out with Arlington’s chief prosecutor, Commonwealth’s Attorney William J. Hassan, they were not to step in until the gang members actually broke the law. The young men were on private property with their weapons in plain view, and under Virginia law that alone wasn’t grounds for an arrest.

The Avengers arrived first, around 8 p.m., some 15 to 20 of them. One officer later told the court that weapons “were lying on the (car) hoods, in the seats, anywhere you looked you could see guns.”

At about 10:30, police picked up two Pagans walking toward the Safeway on Illinois Street with illegal sawed-off shotguns. Then a couple of carloads of Pagans rolled past. Hager says the Avengers threw a tire iron at the lead car.

“I hit the dirt”

At 11:04 p.m., just as the waiting officers were changing shifts, shots rang out from the woods behind Gifford’s Ice Cream, near the Safeway. According to a police report, a 21-year-old Pagan from Vienna named W. Ray Cockerille fired from the bushes behind the Safeway. The Avengers fired back.

“I hit the dirt and called for help, but I had to repeat myself because the sound of the shots covered my radio transmission,” a police sergeant told the Washington Post.

Somehow, nobody was killed. By Clark’s account, about 100 shots were fired, police were within 40 feet of the crossfire, and the only injury was a state trooper whose leg was grazed by a ricochet. A parked car and a vacant store window took pellets. Officers later joked about the “most shots fired in Arlington since 1865” and the shooters’ lousy aim.

Police arrested 16 gang members that night and more the next day, impounded eight cars, and laid out what they had seized: rifles, pistols, blackjacks, sawed-off shotguns and a baseball bat studded with nails.

Rifles, shotguns, pistols, knives and clubs laid on a checkered floor beneath an Avengers jacket with a Maltese cross and skull
Weapons and an Avengers jacket seized by Arlington police the night of the Lee-Harrison shootout, June 14, 1966. Photo: Arlington County Police Department, via Arlington Historical Magazine.

Who was to blame?

The bigger fight was over the police. Why had they watched a gunfight build for hours?

A Washington Post editorial blasted the “appalling ineptitude” of the Arlington police. County Board member Kenneth Haggerty said, “It seems incredible that hoodlums could gather with guns while police watched them have a shooting war,” and called for a special meeting on the gun laws. Board chairman Leo Urbanske cancelled it after Hassan protested that a public meeting would jeopardize his prosecutions.

Hassan and Chief Fawver argued that a tip, and a group of young men standing quietly on private property, were not grounds for an arrest.

Two days after the shootout, Hassan showed he could act before anyone fired a shot. Police arrested two Avengers, Donald Morley and John Thomas, right after they bought two shotguns, a rifle and 100 rounds of ammunition at a pawn shop in Lyon Village. Hassan cited a county ordinance allowing arrests of people whose conduct was “reasonably calculated to cause consternation and alarm in the community.”

On June 22, representatives of the two gangs met to try to reach a kind of “cold war”: nobody would carry weapons or wear colors in the other’s territory.

At its next regular meeting, about ten days after the shootout, the County Board voted 2-1 to commend the police. “It’s easy to Monday morning quarterback after the shooting is over,” Urbanske told the Evening Star.

The verdicts

Of the gang members tried in Judge J. Jackson Embrey’s courtroom, eleven were found guilty of disorderly conduct and inciting to riot, and one was acquitted. Most drew fines of $100 to $250 and suspended sentences. Morley got 30 days, with all but five suspended.

A line of young men in short sleeves, handcuffed in pairs, walking past parked cars
Pagan W. Ray Cockerille, far right, handcuffed to Avenger Donald L. Morley as gang members are led to a hearing at the Arlington courthouse, June 1966. Photo: Charles Del Vecchio, The Washington Post, via Arlington Historical Magazine.

The bigger charges mostly fell away. An attempted murder charge against Cockerille was dropped when witnesses failed to appear, and a charge against Pagan Arthur Molle for shooting into an occupied car was dismissed. The two Pagans caught with sawed-off shotguns pleaded guilty in federal court in Alexandria on July 27 and got suspended sentences.

Hager still remembered the judge’s warning in 2008: “If I see any two of you guys wearing jackets, I’ll lock you up.”

What became of them

Dutch Burhans, whose fight with Hager set the whole thing in motion, wasn’t at the lot that night. He went on to become president of the Pagans in the mid-1970s and was shot and killed in a Fairfax City apartment in January 1980.

Hager kept his Avengers jacket, his scrapbook and, as of 2008, the same 1965 Impala, with more than 220,000 miles on it. In 2016, on the 50th anniversary, he stood in the Lee-Harrison lot and walked a small crowd through the night it all happened.

For one night, a grocery store lot was the most dangerous place in Arlington, and the county spent the rest of that summer arguing over why the police let it happen.

If you grew up around here, you probably know the area better as the place you buy groceries.

The Email

Liked this one? Get more tomorrow.

Lost Washington stories in your inbox most mornings: the newest, plus a few from the archive.

From a recent email
  • Senator John Stennis Shot in Northwest Washington in 1973
  • Chateau Bonaparte: The Bonaparte Family’s K Street Home
  • Japan’s First Embassy to America Arrives in 1860

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

We use AI to help research, write and edit stories across our sites. Here’s how we use AI.Suggest a correction

Pass it on

Know someone who’d like this?

Send it to them.

Email it
Washington Post map of new suburban subdivisions around Washington in 1961Read nextWashington’s New Suburbs in 1961: 57 Subdivisions on One MapA September 9, 1961 Washington Post map of 57 new subdivisions in Maryland and Virginia, transcribed with builders, prices and 1961 driving directions.Keep reading16 min read
On the Atlas

See where this happened.

Lee Harrison Shopping Center

Open the map