“This means money; we need money and we want to have it.”
That’s what one of the robbers said, as Sen. John C. Stennis remembered it, outside his house at 3609 Cumberland Street NW on the evening of January 30, 1973. Moments later the 71-year-old Mississippi Democrat, chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee and, as the Washington Post put it, “one of the most influential men on Capitol Hill,” had been shot twice, in the leg and in the chest.
He said he didn’t go down. As he told a federal jury that fall, “I grabbed my leg, but I did not fall. I visioned that if I went to the ground, then I’d be shot in the head.”
Then he walked into his own house.
He lived to play a part in Watergate, too. That fall, the White House plan to settle the fight over President Nixon’s secret tapes carried his name, and when the special prosecutor refused it, the result was the Saturday Night Massacre.

A senator walks home from his car
His Cumberland Street house was a short distance north of the Appleton Street house where Marilyn Monroe stayed in 1957.
Stennis had spent the day at the Capitol, left about 6 p.m. for a National Guard Association reception, and driven himself home, as he usually did. The Washington Post put the time he parked in front of the house at about 7:40 p.m.
On the witness stand that October, Stennis took the jury through it. As he turned off 36th Street onto Cumberland, a car shot past him on the left. “What attracted my attention was the gunning of the motor,” he said. It stopped a little beyond where he parked. “I didn’t pay it any special attention.”
“I got out of the car . . . slammed the door, and locked it, and started into my home 10 or 12 steps away. I saw two young men walking rather fast, almost in a trot, running down the street toward me, almost in a lope-like.”
One of them made “a right-angle turn,” bumped into him and told him what they were after.

A watch, a key and some change
Stennis handed over a gold pocket watch, his Phi Beta Kappa key (the honor society’s emblem) and a little change. The Post’s first report on January 31 listed his wallet with credit cards, the watch, the key “and a 25-cent piece.” At trial he remembered 35 cents.
He didn’t go quietly. He talked. He told the robbers the watch had recently been valued at $800, and offered to send them money later if there was any way he could get it to them.
“He took the watch and I undertook to outtalk him,” Stennis testified. “He didn’t pay any attention to that. I was trying to negotiate a settlement with him, so to speak.”
When one of them “undertook to handle me physically,” Stennis said, he started to fight back, and “thing began to move mighty fast then.” Then he saw the gun.
The first shot hit his left thigh and shattered on the bone. The second came after a pause the senator described this way:
I was looking at a smoking gun barrel. I gave an alarm. The man stepped back and fired again, and hit me below the nipple, below the heart.
Asked what the gunman said before he fired, Stennis answered: “He said, ‘I’m gonna kill you anyway . . .'” The night of the shooting, police had passed along two versions from the senator: “Now we’re going to shoot you anyway,” or “We ought to shoot you anyway.”
As the two ran off, west on Cumberland and north on Reno Road, Stennis said they let out a “sound of jubilation or triumph.”
“He walked into the house”
Here’s the part that still gets us. The Post’s Martin Weil traced the senator’s path from the curb to his door: a 10-foot sidewalk, four concrete steps, 20 more feet of sidewalk, three more steps and a six-foot landing. “Finally, and unaided, he entered the house.”

“He walked into the house,” a Senate colleague, Henry Jackson, later quoted Coy Stennis, the senator’s wife, as saying. She had heard the shots, looked out and seen two figures running.
Stennis lay down on the couch and, fully conscious, told her to call the police and Walter Reed.
The call reached the fire department at 7:49 p.m. Ambulance No. 2 rolled from 1700 Lanier Place NW, three miles away, and its crew didn’t know whom they were going to get until the radio told them near Connecticut and Porter. Pvt. Robert S. Adams told the Post:
When we arrived, the senator was on the couch in the living room. He was conscious and was asking ‘Where is the ambulance?’ I said, ‘We’re here now.’
The attendants planned to take him to George Washington University Hospital. The senator and his wife asked for Walter Reed Army Medical Center instead, because, Mrs. Stennis said, he’d had surgery there before and “they know him.” He was admitted at 8:03 p.m.
The chest bullet had traveled across his body, through the stomach, the pancreas and the colon, before lodging in his back. His surgery ran past 2 a.m.
A president at the bedside
A week after the shooting, the Post’s front page still had him in grave condition. That same day, February 7, President Richard Nixon made an unannounced visit to Walter Reed and then talked to reporters outside. Stennis, he said, had made “a remarkable comeback from where he was yesterday.” Nixon had called his own physician, Dr. Walter Tkach, at midnight to check, and the doctors told him the senator’s “tissues are much younger than a man of 72 would normally have.” (He was 71.)

Then the detail only a visitor could offer. Stennis, Nixon said, “has always had a grip of steel,” and the handshake he got that day was as strong as ever.
A manhunt, and an argument on the street
The Post called it “one of the most intensive manhunts in Washington history.” By the time arrests came on March 12, a 30-man team of police and FBI agents had questioned at least 1,000 people, and rewards of more than $60,000 had been posted.
The suspects were two brothers from 13th Street NE, Tyrone I. Marshall, 19, and John Marshall, 21, and Derick Holloway, 18, of South Dakota Avenue NE. The government would say Tyrone fired the gun and Holloway drove the getaway car. Police sources said Stennis’s watch and a small-caliber handgun turned up at the 13th Street address.
The break, the Post reported, came when a passerby overheard Tyrone Marshall arguing with his wife on the street, and heard her accuse him of shooting Stennis.
Acting FBI Director L. Patrick Gray III announced that all three would be charged under what the Post called “the federal congressional assassination statute, a 1971 law making it a federal crime to shoot a congressman.” The law was barely two years old.
“I believe that is the man that had the pistol”
John Marshall pleaded guilty in April 1973.
Tyrone Marshall went to trial in U.S. District Court on October 2, 1973, and the government’s first witness was the victim. Stennis, noticeably thinner than the 171 pounds he said he weighed that January night, walked in behind an FBI agent. Tyrone Marshall kept his eyes closed as Stennis began: “My name is Stennis . . . John C. Stennis.”
On the stand he started to point out “a gentleman at that table over there.” The jury was sent out, and Stennis told the judge, “I believe that is the man that had the pistol.” Judge Joseph C. Waddy ruled the jury couldn’t hear it and told jurors to ignore it.
Holloway, the alleged getaway driver, had been given limited immunity, but he still refused to answer questions as a government witness, and the judge jailed him for contempt of court.
Within days the government gave him complete immunity, which meant he could never be prosecuted, and prosecutors said he was ready to tell the jury how the three had driven around Northwest Washington for nearly an hour that night looking for someone to rob.
On October 8, days into the trial, Tyrone Marshall pleaded guilty in a way that let him keep insisting he hadn’t done it. It’s called an Alford plea. A federal appeals court later summed up his reasoning:
While he had not committed the offenses charged, he recognized that the strength of the Government’s case thus far presented minimized his chances of acquittal.
By then his brother John had been sentenced to 15 years. Tyrone was sentenced on March 29, 1974. He was young enough for a more lenient youth sentence, but when Judge Waddy announced an adult prison term, with at least 10 years to serve, Tyrone shouted, “I ain’t accepting that sentence,” and fought three U.S. marshals as they took him out, while his father called from the back of the courtroom: “Tyrone!”
Judge Waddy wouldn’t let him take the plea back, and in 1975 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit dismissed his appeal.

Back in the Senate
Stennis left Walter Reed on July 30, 1973, six months to the day after the shooting, and turned 72 on August 3. He returned to the Senate floor on September 5, 1973, to a round of welcomes from colleagues. “John, I join in this warm welcome to you,” Sen. Edmund Muskie said, according to the Congressional Record.

He went right back to work, and within weeks he was in the middle of Watergate. That fall the Nixon White House floated the so-called Stennis Compromise, under which the senator would vouch for a summary of the Watergate tapes. Special prosecutor Archibald Cox insisted on the full recordings, and on October 20, 1973, Nixon ordered him fired. Attorney General Elliot Richardson, the man beside Stennis in that January hearing photo, resigned rather than do it.

It became known as the Saturday Night Massacre, and the House Historian says it pushed the House to act: on October 23 alone, members introduced more than a dozen resolutions calling for an impeachment inquiry.
Stennis chaired Armed Services until 1981, later chaired Appropriations, and served as President pro tempore. When he retired on January 3, 1989, he had been in the Senate more than 41 years.
He died in Mississippi on April 23, 1995, at 93.
Next time you’re on Cumberland Street, a quiet block of upper Northwest just off Reno Road, picture a 71-year-old senator with a bullet in his chest, counting off the steps to his front door.
Beside Stennis in this October 1972 photograph is Alexander Haig, later Reagan’s secretary of state. After Reagan was shot outside the Washington Hilton in 1981, Haig told reporters, “I am in control here.”

Liked this one? Get more tomorrow.
Lost Washington stories in your inbox most mornings: the newest, plus a few from the archive.
This storySenator John Stennis Shot in Northwest Washington in 1973
What Was a Herdic Cab? An 1881 Race Down Pennsylvania Avenue
Langley, the Wright Brothers, and the Fight Over First Flight
Free. Unsubscribe anytime.
AI helped research and write this story and restore the featured photograph in black and white. The original newspaper photograph appears at the end of the article. Here’s how we use AI.Suggest a correction

